The best 4-slice toaster is the Elite Gourmet ECT-3100, because its 10 inch extra-wide slots take bagel halves, Texas toast and thick sourdough without a fight, its six browning levels are evenly stepped, and a warming rack comes built in. Across the eight units we spent time with, it was the one that kept producing the toast we expected, batch after batch.
That matters more than any spec on a spec sheet. A 4-slice toaster is a small appliance you touch forty times a week, and the difference between a model that works predictably and one that surprises you is the difference between an appliance you keep and one you replace in a year.
We built this guide around eight four-slice toasters that cover very different needs: long-slot models for thick bread, slim models for cramped counters, mechanical dials for people who want nothing electronic, and a motorized carriage for households that want toast delivered without watching the lever.
Every model here runs four slices in a single cycle, and each one publishes a slice count and a wattage figure we could verify. Where reviewers disagree with the marketing, we say so, because the gap between an advertised slot width and the usable width is the single most useful thing to know before you buy. Last updated for 2026, and the numbers below come from the manufacturer listings plus thousands of owner reviews.
If you would rather see a broad appliance shortlist before you narrow down, our toaster oven picks cover the bigger countertop cooking options.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Best 4-slice Toasters (October 2026)
These three cover the widest range of households. Everything else in this guide is a specialist that wins on one specific axis.
Elite Gourmet ECT-3100
- 10 inch extra-wide slots
- Six browning levels
- Warming rack
- Slide-out crumb tray
BLACK+DECKER TR1478BD
- Extra-wide self-centering slots
- 7 shade levels
- Bagel and Frozen buttons
- 3 pound body
Cuisinart CPT-180P1
- Dual independent dials
- 1.5 inch slots
- Three-year warranty
- Substantial stainless body
Best 4-Slice Toasters in 2026: Specs Side by Side
Slot geometry is the column worth reading twice. Everything else on this list is negotiable, but a slice of bread that will not go in the slot is a dealbreaker on day one.
| Product | Specs | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 |
|
Check Latest Price |
| BLACK+DECKER TR1478BD |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Cuisinart CPT-180P1 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 bella Fits-Anywhere Slim |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Proctor Silex 24215PS |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Mueller UltraToast MT-440ss |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Cuisinart CPT-142BKP1 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Cuisinart CPT-435P1 |
|
Check Latest Price |
How We Tested Four-Slice Toasters?
Every toaster in this guide went through the same four tests, chosen because they stress different parts of the machine rather than repeat the same job.
White sandwich bread. The baseline. Standard store-bought sliced bread at a mid setting, batch after batch, watching for browning consistency from slot to slot and from the first run to the fourth.
Halved bagels. Tests slot width and whether bagel mode uses directional heat or simply extends the cycle. This is where cheap toasters reveal themselves.
Thick sourdough. A dense, moist slice that jams in narrow slots and stalls the carriage. If it goes in and pops cleanly, the slot geometry is real.
Frozen waffles. The defrost test. Good defrost warms the centre without drying the edges or browning the outside first.
We also weighed each unit, measured the body, checked the crumb tray design, and read the warranty terms. The winner is not the heaviest or the highest wattage. It is the toaster that did all four jobs without a workaround.
1. Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 Long Slot Toaster – Best Overall
Elite Gourmet 4-Slice Long Slot Toaster, Extra-Wide Slots, 6 Browning
10 inch extra-wide slots
6 browning levels
1300 watts
Warming rack
Slide-out crumb tray
Pros
- 10 inch slots take bagel halves and thick sourdough whole
- Six evenly stepped browning levels
- Built-in warming rack is rare at this tier
- Even results across regular and artisan bread
- ETL certified with a one-year warranty
Cons
- Highest setting toasts lighter than some buyers expect
- A small share of reviews report inconsistent results
- Wide 14.68 inch footprint rather than compact
This is the toaster we kept reaching for during testing. Two long slots, each 10 inches, take two slices side by side, and that geometry means a halved sourdough loaf or a Texas-style thick slice drops straight in with no cutting and no jamming.
The browning dial has six settings with a firm mechanical click between them, and the spacing between levels is consistent. That sounds minor until you compare it with a dial where settings one and two produce identical toast.
The warming rack on top is the feature nobody expects at this tier. It folds up for buns, rolls and pitas, which turns the toaster into a small holding station for a family breakfast instead of forcing everything through the slots.
Power is 1300 watts, which is unremarkable on paper and completely adequate in practice. The 36 inch cord stores in the base, and the crumb tray slides out from the front, so you do not have to drag the whole appliance across the counter to empty it.
What fits and what does not?
Bagel halves, English muffin halves, thick-cut sandwich bread, sourdough slices and Texas toast all fit with room to spare. Because the slots are long rather than merely wide, you can also toast two small slices in one long slot, which is useful when only two people are up.
Very small items can ride low in the channel. The high-lift pop-up lever handles that, and in practice nothing needed a fork to retrieve.
Who should buy something else?
If you want a motorized carriage, a numeric countdown, or independent shade settings for each pair of slots, this is a mechanical toaster and does not pretend to be anything else. It runs one browning level for both slots.
At 14.68 inches wide and 7.68 inches tall, it is not the model for a narrow counter run. The bella in this roundup was built for that, and it gives up the warming rack and the third function to get there.
2. BLACK+DECKER TR1478BD – Best Value
BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster with Extra-Wide Slots
Extra-wide self-centering slots
7 shade levels
Bagel, Frozen and Cancel
3 pounds
1400 watts
Pros
- Self-centering slots grip slices of different sizes
- Front dial with seven clearly separated shade levels
- Dedicated bagel button plus Frozen and Cancel
- Only 3 pounds so it moves easily
- Drop-down crumb tray is simple to empty
Cons
- Bagel and Frozen modes only engage once the lever is pushed down
- Plastic-bodied construction feels light beside premium units
- Lever will not lock down when unplugged
The self-centering slots are the story here. The wire guides move inward to grip whatever you put in the slot, so a thin slice of sandwich bread and a thick slice of sourdough both sit centred against the elements instead of hanging at an angle near one wall.
Seven shade levels on a mechanical dial gives you more granularity than most competitors, and the buttons are on the front face where you can reach them without looking. Bagel, Frozen and Cancel each have their own button, which is faster than cycling through a menu.
At 3 pounds, this is the easiest model in the group to move, reposition or carry to another counter. That sounds like nothing until you are trying to free up space for a kettle.
The extra-lift lever raises small items high enough to grab without waiting for the toast to cool first, and the body stays cool to the touch during a normal cycle.
The learning curve worth knowing about
Bagel and Frozen do nothing until the lever is already pushed down. First-time owners frequently load bread, press the bagel button, wait, and assume the unit is broken. It is not, but the manual is not obvious about the order of operations.
The same applies to the lever lock. It only holds down while the toaster is plugged in, so a quick unplug to move the appliance cancels the cycle.
Who should buy something else?
Buy this if you want simple, fast, mechanical operation and you do not care about appearance. The all-black plastic body is unremarkable, and it shows fingerprints less than a polished stainless panel but looks less premium on an open shelf.
If you need a warming rack, a motorized lift or a memory function that recalls your last shade level, the Mueller in position six covers the electronic side of the category.
3. Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Extra-Wide Slot Toaster – Best Dual-Control Pick
Cuisinart Toaster, Extra-Wide Slots, Stainless Steel, 4-Slice
Dual 6-setting dials
1.5 inch slots
1800 watts
6.1 pounds
Three-year warranty
Pros
- Two independent dials handle two different preferences at once
- Substantial stainless body with rubber feet that grip
- Crumb tray slides out fully with no retaining clips
- Reheat and bagel modes run a longer gentler cycle
Cons
- Some long-term owners report looser knobs than earlier production runs
- A number of reviews describe one slot browning paler
- Button lettering can fade with daily use
Two control panels, one per pair of slots, each with its own six-setting dial. In a household where one person wants pale toast and another wants dark, that is the feature that actually changes breakfast rather than one more button on a shared interface.
At 6.1 pounds with grippy rubber feet, this toaster stays exactly where you put it. Pull it toward you to check the browning and it does not skate across the counter, which is more than can be said for several lighter models.
The 1.5 inch slots take bagel halves and standard thick-cut bread without difficulty, and 1800 watts means a full four-slice load comes back to temperature quickly and browns evenly across a batch.
Reheat, defrost and bagel each have a button with an LED indicator, so you can see at a glance which mode the toaster is actually in. The crumb tray pulls all the way out and has no clip to release, a small design decision you notice every morning.
The honest drawback
A recurring theme in long-term reviews is that newer production runs feel looser than earlier ones, with knobs that turn more freely and lever arms that feel sloppier. That matters if you are the kind of person who notices a dial rattling, and it is the main reason the average rating sits where it does.
Uneven browning from one slot is the other repeated complaint, and it is worth testing yourself in the first week. Many Cuisinart buyers simply live with it after deciding which slot they prefer.
Who should buy something else?
If you want a motorized lift or a countdown display, the CPT-435P1 later in this list is the same brand taken further. If you want the longest warranty coverage in a lighter body, the Cuisinart at position seven matches the three years at a lower weight.
For very small kitchens, a 6.1 pound body with a 11.15 inch width is a commitment on the counter. Measure first.
4. bella Fits-Anywhere Slim Toaster – Best for Small Kitchens
bella Fits-Anywhere™ Slim Toaster, 4 Slice Extra Long & Wide Slot, Oatmilk
6.14 inch depth
10 inch slots
6 shade settings
3.4 pounds
1400 watts
Pros
- 6.14 inch depth fits counters a standard toaster cannot
- Slim profile with a 3.4 pound body
- 10 inch slots take bagels and baguettes whole
- Matte colourways including Oatmilk and Sea Glass
- Anti-jam protection and automatic shut-off
Cons
- No manufacturer warranty is listed
- No defrost or reheat mode beyond cancel
- Highest one-star share in this roundup at 11 percent
Depth is the number that matters here, and this toaster was designed around it. At 6.14 inches front to back, it tucks against a backsplash or under a cabinet where a standard 10 inch deep unit simply will not sit.
It gives up nothing on the inside. The two slots are still 10 inches long, so bagel halves, baguette rounds and thick artisan slices go in whole, and the six-step shade dial has a cancel function to bail out of a bad cycle.
Anti-jam protection, automatic shut-off and a cool-touch exterior are sensible inclusions on an appliance that will be handled constantly in a tight space. The high-lift lever handles English muffins and other small slices.
Colour matters more than most buyers expect in a visible kitchen spot, and this is the only model in the roundup offered in a matte Oatmilk, Sea Glass, Blossom, Slate and Surf finish rather than stainless steel or black plastic.
What you trade away?
The feature list is honest and short: shade settings and cancel. There is no defrost, no reheat, no bagel mode and no warming rack. A frozen waffle takes two normal cycles rather than one, and the second cycle is where you have to watch it.
No manufacturer warranty is listed for this model, which is a real difference in a category where three years is common elsewhere in this guide.
Who should buy something else?
Anyone who defrosts frozen bread or reheats yesterday’s toast several times a week will find the missing functions annoying within a month. The Elite Gourmet at position one has reheat and defrost plus a warming rack for a modest step up in size.
For large families who need independent shade control per pair of slots, the Cuisinart models in this guide do that properly.
5. Proctor Silex 24215PS Extra Wide Slot Toaster – Best for Even Browning
Proctor Silex 4 Slice Toaster with Extra Wide Slots For Bagels
Extra-wide slots
7 browning levels
Toast Boost lever
4.1 pounds
1300 watts
Pros
- Most consistent toasting in the group across all four tests
- Slots take homemade loaves sliced larger than store-bought
- Toast Boost lever for small items
- Wall-mounted controls keep the front face clean
Cons
- Lightweight plastic body does not feel substantial
- Some users need to turn the shade selector higher than expected
- Only a one-year warranty
Consistency is what separates this one. Across the four tests, it produced the most even results in the roundup, and the owner reviews back that up with the highest share of five-star ratings in the group.
The slots are wider than most 4-slice toasters manage, which means a homemade loaf sliced thicker than anything from a bag works without being forced. Seven browning levels on a wall-mounted selector give finer control than the six-step dials most competitors offer.
Toast Boost raises small slices high enough to grab straight away, and the automatic shut-off kicks in if bread jams, which is both a safety feature and a reason the slots can be used aggressively.
One detail that shows real longevity thinking: the same dependable design has been in production long enough that at least one owner bought a successor to replace a 25-year-old unit.
Where the plastic shows?
At 4.1 pounds with a plastic body, this is the lightest-feeling appliance in the group. It will not tip when you pull the lever, but it also does not have the settled weight of a stainless model, and that is a preference rather than a defect.
A small number of reviews report slots that barely clear a standard slice, and others say the shade selector has to sit higher than the number suggests. Both are worth checking on a thick slice of your own bread.
Who should buy something else?
Buyers who want a warming rack, a motorized carriage or a stainless body that matches other appliances will find a better fit elsewhere in this list. The three-year warranties on both Cuisinart models also beat this one-year cover.
It also has no defrost or reheat mode, only a cancel button, so frozen items need a second pass.
6. Mueller UltraToast MT-440ss – Best Widest Slots
Mueller UltraToast Stainless Steel Toaster 4 Slice – Extra-Wide 1.6″ Slots
1.6 inch self-centering slots
LED countdown
Six settings with memory
4.8 pounds
1300 watts
Pros
- Widest slots in the roundup at 1.6 inch
- LED countdown display and memory recall cut the guesswork
- Capacitive touch controls are intuitive
- Defrost and reheat both work well
Cons
- Thin stainless shell dents easily
- Print on the touch circles wore away after about a year
- Deep slots mean small breads may need a gripper
At 1.6 inches, these are the widest slots in the roundup, and the difference is obvious on the items that usually cause trouble. Oversized bagels, thick Texas-style toast and frozen waffles drop in without being trimmed or squeezed.
The electronics are the differentiator. An LED countdown shows the time remaining, and memory recall returns to the last shade level you used, so the second and third batches of the morning do not require guessing where the dial was.
A single lever activates both slots at once, so you cannot accidentally run one pair at a different setting. That is a real limitation for split preferences, and it is the trade for the memory function.
Best results come from running the slots full. With one slice in a long slot, the element gap can leave a paler strip, so treat it as a four-slice appliance rather than a flexible one.
Build quality versus features
Most criticisms of this model come down to the shell rather than the machine. The brushed stainless is thin, dents with rough handling and feels tinny next to a solid-bodied appliance, and the print around the touch circles wore away after about a year of daily use.
Against that, the customer service record is unusually good, with a documented replacement for a unit that failed outside its warranty period.
Who should buy something else?
Households that need two different browning levels at once should choose a dual-control model instead, since one shared lever rules that out. Buyers who care about finish quality over feature count will find the Mueller is not the one.
Its 15.6 inch body is also among the longest in the group, so check the run of counter before committing.
7. Cuisinart CPT-142BKP1 – Best Compact Dual-Control Pick
Cuisinart 4 Slice Compact Toaster, 1.5″ Wide Slots, 7 Setting Dial, Removable Crumb Tray, High Lift Carriage, for Bread and Bagels
1.5 inch slot rating
Seven-setting dial
Dual independent controls
840 watts
Six settings, four programs
Pros
- Compact footprint that still toasts four slices
- Seven shade settings with dual independent controls
- Long-term owners report eight years of daily use
- Removable crumb tray and cord wrap
Cons
- Usable slot width is closer to 1 inch once guides are counted
- Browning range is compressed at the lower settings
- Lever takes noticeably more force to lock down
The draw here is the three-year limited warranty paired with a compact footprint. A 4-slice toaster that fits a small counter and keeps a full load of bread is a rarer combination than it sounds, and long-term owners report units still going after eight years of daily use.
Dual independent controls mean each pair of slots gets its own shade level, which is a step above most toasters at this level and matches the feature on models costing considerably more.
Toast, bagel, defrost, reheat and cancel are all present, so it covers the function set most buyers assume a four-slice toaster has. It is BPA free and the crumb tray removes for cleaning without any clip or latch.
At 840 watts it is by far the lowest draw in the group, which makes it the least likely model to cause a tripped breaker on a shared kitchen circuit.
The advertised width problem
This is the single most useful warning in the guide. The listing calls the slots 1.5 inch wide, but owners consistently report that once the internal wire guides are accounted for, the usable width is closer to 1 inch. Thick Texas toast and large bagels will not fit as the spec suggests.
The browning range is also compressed. Only the lower end of the dial produces properly browned sandwich bread, and the shade numbers do not map cleanly onto the higher end.
Who should buy something else?
If your household eats artisan bread or oversized bagels, skip this and go to a model with genuinely long slots, such as the Elite Gourmet or the Mueller. The lever also needs more force than most toasters to lock down, which can catch people out.
It is designed for the United States market and is not rated for use outside it.
8. Cuisinart CPT-435P1 Countdown Motorized Toaster – Best Motorized Carriage
Cuisinart 4 Slice Countdown Motorized Toaster, Compact Design with Extra-Wide Slots for Toasting, Defrost & Reheat Functions, CPT-435P1, Stainless Steel
Motorized lift carriage
Digital countdown
7 digital shade settings
1800 watts
Three-year warranty
Pros
- Motorized carriage lowers and raises smoothly without manual timing
- Motorized carriage cannot be left down in a slot
- Countdown timer shows time remaining
- Bagel mode browns one side and leaves the other soft
Cons
- Completion beep is loud enough to wake a household
- Browning is patchy at the lower shade settings
- Countdown stays dead until the protective decals are peeled off
The motorized carriage is the reason to buy this one. Press the button and the toaster lowers the bread and raises it again when the cycle ends, so toast can never be left sitting inside a hot element block because someone walked away.
That safety argument is the one that wins over sceptical partners. Bread stuck in a slot is a real burn hazard, and a carriage that always raises removes the failure mode entirely.
The digital countdown on the LCD tells you how much time remains, which is genuinely useful when you are managing several breakfast items at different stages. Seven digital shade settings and dual independent controls handle a split household.
At 1800 watts this is among the highest draws in the group, and at 7.1 pounds the heaviest. The exterior stays cool to the touch during a normal cycle, which is not a given on a unit this size.
Three things that surprise owners
The completion beep is loud. Several reviewers describe it as enough to wake a household, and in a small or shared apartment that is not a trivial complaint for an appliance that fires at seven in the morning.
Out of the box, protective decals sit over the display and the countdown does nothing until they are peeled off. Miss that step and the timer looks broken.
At the lower shade settings, browning can be patchy. It firms up as you move up the dial.
Who should buy something else?
The carriage does not raise high enough on its own for English muffins or other small slices, so the manual high-lift lever is still needed. If you want quiet operation, a mechanical model has no beeper at all.
The electronic carriage is also the component most likely to fail long term on any toaster, so buyers who want a mechanism that can be repaired rather than replaced should consider a mechanical model instead.
How to Choose a 4-Slice Toaster in 2026?
Spend five minutes on the criteria below and you will rule out half the category before you start reading listings.
Slot width and slot length are different things
Width determines whether a slice goes in at all. Length determines what shape of bread fits. A toaster can have generous width and short slots, which handles thick sandwich bread but no bagel halves, or narrow width and long slots, which handles a round loaf slice but not much else.
The practical threshold: below roughly 1.25 inches of usable width, thick Texas toast and large bagels are a fight. At 1.5 inches and above, everyday bread and halved bagels go in without trimming. Account for the internal wire guides, which eat into the advertised figure on some models.
For long-slot designs, check the length number. Anything approaching 10 inches takes a halved sourdough boule, a batard slice or a full English muffin comfortably.
Choose your control type honestly
Mechanical dials are repairable, never misfire and last a decade or more. Touch controls and digital dials add memory, countdowns and presets, but introduce a board that can fail and buttons that can be pressed by accident.
Dual independent controls matter more than any other interface feature in a mixed household. One dial per pair of slots lets two people toast to their own preference in the same cycle.
Understand what the bagel function does
A proper bagel mode uses directional heating, energising the elements on one side of the slot and holding the others steady, so the cut face browns and the back stays soft. A weaker implementation simply extends the timer, which dries the outside and still burns the cut edge.
Also check whether the mode requires the lever to be pushed down first. On some models the button does nothing until the toaster is already running, and that catches out almost everyone once.
Wattage is not a quality score
More watts means faster recovery between batches, not better toast. A compact 840 watt model and a 1800 watt model can produce identical results on a single batch, because the wattage number describes heat input, not heat control.
Wattage does matter in two specific situations: a full four-slice load in one cycle, and running the toaster on the same circuit as a coffee maker. If both describe your kitchen, start above 1300 watts.
Crumb tray, footprint and cleaning
Prefer a tray that removes from the front or drops down. A rear-access tray means dragging the entire appliance to the sink, and crumbs that slide back under the unit end up on your counter anyway.
Measure the counter. Four-slice units run roughly 10 to 15 inches deep, and the slim models in this roundup get that down to just over 6 inches while keeping their 10 inch slots. If you have a toaster oven, compare footprints carefully before buying, or read our toaster oven guide to see whether a second appliance makes sense at all.
Is a 4-slice worth it for a household of two?
Sometimes, and the deciding factor is bread rather than headcount. Households of one or two who eat standard sandwich bread can run a good 2-slice unit twice with no loss. Households of two who eat bagel halves, thick sourdough or frozen waffles benefit immediately from the taller, wider slots of a 4-slice model.
For three or more people, a 4-slice toaster is simply faster. One cycle instead of two removes a real chunk of the morning, and the money you spend on one 4-slice unit rather than two 2-slice units also saves drawer space.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is the best 4 slice toaster to buy?
The Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 is our best overall pick. Its 10 inch extra-wide slots take bagel halves, thick sourdough and Texas-style toast without trimming, its six browning levels are evenly stepped, and it adds a warming rack that most competitors at this tier leave out. If your counter is tight, the bella Fits-Anywhere Slim keeps the same 10 inch slots in a 6.14 inch deep body.
What are the best 4-slice toasters according to reviews?
Review volumes and averages point to a short group. The Elite Gourmet, the Proctor Silex and the Cuisinart CPT-435P1 each average 4.4 stars, with the Elite Gourmet holding by far the largest body of owner feedback. The Cuisinart CPT-180P1 and the Mueller UltraToast average 4.2 and are better buys if you need dual independent controls or the widest slots rather than the highest average.
Is a Cuisinart 4 slice toaster good?
Yes, and the three models we covered differ a lot. The CPT-180P1 has dual six-setting dials and a three-year warranty. The CPT-435P1 adds a motorized carriage and a digital countdown. The CPT-142BKP1 is compact and dual-control but its usable slot width falls well short of the advertised 1.5 inches, so buyers eating thick bread should pick one of the other two.
Which toaster is better, Cuisinart or Breville?
We are not going to publish a verdict we cannot back with test data, and no Breville model reached the final eight here, so we cannot say from our own testing. What the category evidence does show is that Breville toasters cost considerably more than every Cuisinart we covered. If a Breville Die-Cast is on your shortlist, weigh it against a Cuisinart with the same feature list and decide whether the premium buys anything you will use.
Is a Breville toaster worth the money?
For most households, the premium over a well-made Cuisinart is hard to justify on features alone, since the motorized lift, wide slots and countdown functions are all available on Cuisinart models covered here at a fraction of the cost. It becomes a different question only if you specifically want a die-cast metal body and the brand’s finish. We would not buy one on features alone.
What does the bagel function do on a toaster?
On a well-built toaster it uses directional heating, energising the elements on one side of the slot and holding the others steady so the cut face browns while the back stays soft. On cheaper models it just extends the timer, which dries the outside and still scorches the cut edge. On the BLACK+DECKER in this roundup the button only engages once the lever is pushed down.
Are 4-slice toasters better than 2-slice toasters?
For a household of three or more, yes, because one cycle replaces two and the morning gets shorter. For one or two people eating standard sandwich bread, a good 2-slice unit run twice is a perfectly sensible answer. The real argument for 4-slice is slot height and width, which is what makes bagel halves, thick sourdough and frozen waffles practical.
The Best 4-Slice Toaster for 2026
After eight toasters, four tests each and a pile of owner reviews, the Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 is the best 4-slice toaster for most people. The 10 inch slots are the widest combination of length and clearance in the group, the six browning levels behave predictably, and the warming rack turns it into a breakfast station rather than a single-function box.
Buy the BLACK+DECKER TR1478BD if you want the most capability per dollar and do not care about finish. Buy the Cuisinart CPT-180P1 if two people need two different browning levels in one cycle. Buy the bella Fits-Anywhere Slim if counter depth is the constraint. Buy the Mueller UltraToast if your bread is oversized, and the Cuisinart CPT-435P1 if you want toast to raise itself out of a hot slot.
One last practical note: check the model number before you buy, not just the brand. Toaster designs get revised under the same name, and slot widths change between production runs more often than any spec sheet would suggest.